Help Us Spread the Word

Cat Food Reviews 2012

Best Cat Food

It's not a simple matter to do a complete and fair comparison of all the commercial cat food available. However, if we were to base judgment on ingredients alone, these brands emerge as the strongest. Bear in mind that the best food for your cat greatly depends on your cat's disposition.

Taste of the Wild Cat Food ReviewNatural Balance Cat Food ReviewOrijen Cat Food ReviewHalo Cat Food ReviewNewman
XX
XX
XX
XX
XX
$$$$$$$$$$$

Taste of the Wild cat food is a pretty decent source of nutrition for the cost, if you can find it, that is. The idea behind the brand’s vision is to provide only those ingredients …

(more)

Natural Balance Cat Food is an average cat food brand when it comes to nutrients, taste and cost. Actor Dick Van Patten created the company in 1989 in an effort to create healthy and nutritious …

(more)

Orijen cat food gets the highest possible rating of five stars for its healthy and nutritious cat food made from fresh proteins, fruits, and vegetables. This Canadian company uses human-grade meats such as free-range, antibiotic-free …

(more)

Halo Cat Food gets a very high rating for its healthy and nutritious cat food made with real meats and quality vegetables. The company only uses human-grade meats like chicken, turkey, lamb, wild salmon and …

(more)

We give Newman’s Own Organics Cat Food five stars for its extremely high quality organic ingredients. The company uses only organic meats, grains, and vegetables, and includes no animal by-products, preservatives, or chemical additives. The …

(more)

Customer Reviews

5/11 by Melissa

I changed my cats over to TOTW a little over 2 yrs ago. Both kept vomiting and excreting diarrhea on a regular basis. I had tried other brands such as...

4/27 by Brenda

Can anyone here get a lot # off the bags of previous food your cats liked versus the new batch they won't eat? Is that even possible? I have decided...

Customer Reviews

5/16 by Jacqui

I've noticed in the last few cases of the calorie reduced small cans that there is a lot of water when I open it up. Not only that, the food...

4/27 by Chris

I have had an issue with NB Indoor Ultra (NBIU). I have two cats, one was 2y and the other 4mo old at the time this happened (a few moths...

Customer Reviews

5/3 by Sandy

My 3 Ragdolls have been eating evo for a couple years. With the recall I switched to Origen. I gave only a small amount in with leftover evo (not on...

4/16 by Jeannie

what flavor was the Orijen that you bought? i have 9 cats and not all of them like to eat the same flavor of orijen. Majority of my cats love...

Customer Reviews

4/23 by Kristin

Because there is something in it that some cats just dont like for some weird reason. My cat has never TOUCHED a crumb. I want to know what it is...

3/11 by Rc

Hi EV, Petsmart sells Halo food here in Ontario.

Customer Reviews

4/26 by Diana

I am going through the same thing. My cats is on Hills c/d. I do not like its lack of nutrtional values. I have given my ctas Newmans own before........

4/10 by Britta

I have been feeding Urinary SO by Royal Canin to my male cat. However I was wondering if there is an alternative brand (without prescription needed)that would be compatible? I...

Cat Food Reviews by Brand

Popular Cat Food

Iams Cat Food ReviewMeow Mix Cat Food ReviewPurina ONE Cat Food ReviewWhiskas Cat Food ReviewFriskies Cat Food Review
$$$$$$$

The experts tend to agree with consumers that Iams contains too many fillers to justify its higher cost. Though Iams is available at both discount stores and pet stores, they claim to be a premium …

(more)

Meow Mix Cat Food is like junk food for cats as it tastes good but has little nutritional value. With inferior ingredients at the top of the list as well as the addition of artificial …

(more)

Purina One Cat Food gets a very low rating from us. The company claims to make ‘super premium’ cat food with real poultry and fish and plenty of vitamins for a balanced diet. The ingredient …

(more)

Whiskas Cat Food is a bit of a conundrum. Some formulas contain high levels of meat protein, while others contain cheap fillers and inferior protein sources. Based on this disparity, we give Whiskas Cat Food …

(more)

We give Friskies Cat Food a very low rating for its lack of quality protein and inclusion of cheap fillers. A quick look at the ingredient lists reveals that corn and corn gluten meal are …

(more)

Customer Reviews

4/21 by Gigi

I have tried on two different occasions to change my male cat from the Iams weight and hairball control food to a cheaper version of the same thing. The first...

4/19 by Mop

I don't know much about the manufacturing of IAMS. However, I do know that my cat CANNOT eat anything but IAMS. He won't eat fish, chichen, red meat,tuna,only cat food....

Customer Reviews

5/1 by Olivia

Recently purchased a new bag of Meow Mix Original and my cat has been trowing up several times a day. I'm not even going to wait for a recall to...

4/29 by Chrissy

Ever since we have had our cats we have fed them Meow Mix. When our male Norwegian Forest cat was around five or six, we noticed a dramatic loss of...

Customer Reviews

12/9 by Helen

I've been feeding this to my 2 cats for years and they both love it. It's also very expensive for what's in it. After reading the ingredients here on this...

10/29 by Evi

A decent price and qutaliy, 2010-11-06 This review is from: Purina One Hairball Healthy Weight Its almost a month since I switched my two cats from Purina Meow Mix...

Customer Reviews

4/28 by Judy C

I have been buying Whiskas easy open pouch, choice cuts, chef's favorites for me two indoor cats. I usually buy the 24 pack with four different flavors. In the past...

4/14 by C&Amp;B

My cats have been eating whiskas wet and dry food for a while and I have discovered that they have lots have dandruff and dry skin on their fur and...

Customer Reviews

5/18 by Ellen

My cat loved Rise and Shine, but threw up for 5 days afterwards and didn't eat. After a couple of hundred dollars and fluids, she got better, began eating, and...

5/18 by Stacey

I'm having a similar issue! Friskies canned food (the seafood multipack) has always been okay for my cat, but for the last few days, he's been throwing up and passing...

Cat Food Reviews by Brand

Latest Cat Food Reviews

Kirkland Cat Food ReviewWellness Cat Food ReviewEvolve Cat Food ReviewCastor and Pollux Cat Food ReviewEVO Cat Food Review
XX
XX
XX
XX
XX
$$$$$$$$$$

Kirkland is a well-known, reputable brand name that seems to be getting it right with their cat food products. Both the Super Premium Maintenance Cat Formula and the Adult Cat Healthy Weight and Hairball Control …

(more)

We give Wellness Cat Food five stars for its natural, nutritious ingredients. All of the formulas use some form of healthy meat as the main ingredient. The company claims that the meats used in the …

(more)

We believe that although Evolve Cat Food does contain a moderate level of carbohydrates, it still has the makings of a highly nutritious and tasty cat food. The food comes in three formulas, Kitten, Cat, ...

(more)

We give five stars to Castor & Pollux Organix Cat Food for its healthy, natural ingredients and lack of fillers. The company uses USDA certified organic meats in their formulas, which means that the meats …

(more)

EVO Cat Food is a definite winner in the cat food market. Natura Pet, the creator of EVO cat food, made a revolutionary step by eliminating all grains from their pet food formulas. The dry …

(more)

Customer Reviews

5/13 by Barack

You truly believe that cat food, regardless of brand, is responsible for your cats' troubles? This product would be pulled off the shelf so quick if this were the case,...

5/11 by Pam

I heard good things about the Kirkland cat food so have been buying it for the past few months. 4 of my 8 cats have developed skin allergies and one...

Customer Reviews

5/17 by Dee

I have noticed the same thing. Normally, I could only find the cans with a 7W code locally, and until a few months ago, the food seemed fine; every now...

5/5 by Sandcat

Well, I noticed the same problem. Suddenly the food was dry and burnt looking and smelled burnt too. My cats refused to eat it. The owner of a local pet...

Customer Reviews

5/14 by Vanessa

I start my Cleo on Evolve about six months ago and notice at great different. Not only was she no longer always eating but her coat improve so much!!! I...

5/1 by Diana

Yet another "Pet Food Nazi" who thinks they love their pet more than you love yours if you fail to pass their "Food Test". Heaven forbid you don't feed raw!!!...

Customer Reviews

3/18 by Wlfheart

To all the people complaining about Merrick recalls. MERRICK DOG OR CAT FOODS HAVE NEVER BEEN RECALLED so quit spreading your lies or misinformation. Merrick's recalls lies within their treats...

11/23 by Shari Peterson

I am very disappointed at the reformulation of the Natural Ultramix cat food. The cats loved it. I had been looking for a cat food they would like for years...

Customer Reviews

5/14 by Deborah Mc Call

As I understand the recall, some of the food had salmonella contamination which is a bacterium, NOT a virus. If your vet told you your cat was sick from a...

5/11 by Marcia

I fed my Bengal EVO Turkey and Chicken from the 2.2 lb recalled bag. He got deathly ill and 2 months later is still fragile and barely eating or moving....

Cat Food Reviews by Brand
Blue Buffalo Cat Food ReviewScience Diet Cat Food ReviewFancy Feast Cat Food ReviewRoyal Canin Cat Food Review9 Lives Cat Food Review
XX
XX
XX
XX
XX
$$$$$$$$$

Blue Buffalo Cat Food gets our highest rating of five stars. The company works with veterinarians and animal nutritionists to create wholesome pet foods that contain a blend of real meat, garden veggies, and whole …

(more)

Science Diet is a relatively popular brand that is high on the cost spectrum but unfortunately low on the nutritional spectrum. Although it is touted as a premium diet, it contains nearly all the same …

(more)

Fancy Feast is not a particularly well-loved food by the experts. Full of filler and less-than-stellar ingredients, it is considered to be one of the worst foods on the market. While it is quite inexpensive, ...

(more)

Some cat owners need to know that they are feeding their felines the finest food on the market. Many cat lovers have gravitated to Royal Canin’s lineup of food products, believing that the brand offers …

(more)

9 Lives Cat Food gets an average review for its mixed bag of varieties. Some varieties of the dry and wet food contain healthy ingredients for a balanced cat diet, while others seem to miss …

(more)

Customer Reviews

5/16 by J Knapp

1 dog 8 cats all have been on BB forever. Now they refuse to eat it...and if they get hungry and do eat it...they throw up. We did research and...

5/15 by Megan

Gave my cats diarrhea even though I was transitioning them gradually. When they didn't have diarrhea and had regular poos, it had the most disgusting, potent smell, that would stink...

Customer Reviews

5/16 by James H

I have experienced the same with my to 12+ females. They hate the new formula Science Diet Longevity. Wont eat it unless forced by starvation. They loved the old formula.

5/15 by J Knapp

Question for anyone. Hills Science diet doesn't get good reviews. Hills Ideal cat food has okay reviews....how so if both are made by Hills? Looking for another brand of cat...

Customer Reviews

5/5 by Stef

Full of junk. More like a treat for my cat like chocolate is for me. His regular diet is Orijen. Free-run chicken and turkey, wild caught fish, whole eggs, fruit,...

5/5 by Steffany

Omg hope no one believes that.

Customer Reviews

5/16 by Susan

I bought a bag of royal canin urinary so from my vet. The cats ate the food for almost two weeks. One of my cats vomited and died. I noticed...

4/14 by Haley

I am in the EXACT same boat. I'm so frustrated by this situation because I feel tied to the food (and the veterinarian for prescriptions). Please let me know if...

Customer Reviews

5/14 by Rose

Um, you need to take the wet food OUT of the can before giving it to your kitty. You wouldn't eat food straight out of a can, so why would...

3/26 by Alexis Roo S.

okay Im writing this to tell you that this morning I was getting my cat some of your canned cat food and he was so exited when I took the...

Cat Food Reviews by Brand

Business / Industry

The Pleasure of Their Company

There's a lot of science behind those little tins.

Big Business of Cat Food The commercials begin with a can being opened gently, with each tasty morsel spooned out into a crystal bowl. The dinner bell beckons. The cat runs swiftly, anxious to begin such a luxurious feast. The owner watches nearby, glad to see that her cat's finicky behavior towards dinnertime is over. In cat food commercials the owner seems to eat, if not exist, on the same level as the cat. Dog food is placed in bowls then lowered to the floor; not so with cat food. The owner invariably follows the cat's lead, stretching out in comfort and relief that all is right with the world. She props her head on her hand, the cat a study in contentment. How pet food is packaged, sold, and promoted mimics, or at least reflects, the larger view that there are "dog people" and there are "cat people."

Belts were tightened, but apparently not collars

Little wonder. There are 38.9 million households in the United States that own cats - though most cat lovers would grant that "ownership," as commonly understood, is often a two-way street. Further, there are within those dwellings, a total of 86.4 million cats meaning that where there is one cat there is often at least one other, according to the American Pet Products Association (APPA).1 Cats may indeed display more independence for days on end, even being able to find food for itself out of doors, but they all come home for dinner at last. The sales of pet food was expected to jump 4%,2 to just under $53 billion dollars in 2012 over 2011, according to the same organization. With each household spending about $220 annually on cat food, producers are aware of how valuable the market is. What is more notable, however, is that even the most cursory survey of industry statistics shows a massive sales jump of about a billion dollars more in annual cat food sales over the past decade - a period of severe economic slump. Belts were tightened, but apparently not collars.

... the FDA ensures that standards are met within our borders even when components come from countries ...

Many factors are at play of course: the trend towards smaller families means that more and more homes can accommodate a pet; cats especially are more adaptable to smaller spaces so are ideal for apartment dwellers; and pet food manufacturers are putting more care into their product, with a consequent rise in consumer confidence. Cat food is such a lucrative market that ingredients are monitored by the federal Food and Drug Administration (FDA).3 While most of the food supplied comes from within the US, the FDA ensures that standards are met within our borders even when components come from countries with less stringent ideas of safety or label integrity.

Cat food, moreover, is not simply meat and vegetables assembled into some tasty stew

Cat food, moreover, is not simply meat and vegetables assembled into some tasty stew. The chemistry behind the composition could be crafted by nutritionists and dieticians - as indeed they are. The Pet Food Institute (PFI), a lobbying group for the industry, extols the care and reliability taken when producing food for the household tabby. Care is taken especially, says the PFI, to remove any trace or remote chance of bacteria or mold in cat food, as cats can be particularly vulnerable to food-borne illnesses. The APPA offers guidelines on its Web site outlining and enforcing strict adherence to guidelines set forth by the federal government and other pet associations. Higher end cat food is readily available with assurances of quality and universal appeal to the more choosy eaters of the feline world. Cat owners claim that the calming effect of cats can help their owners through miserable times such as having illnesses or during stressful periods so a splurge on upscale food might be a just reward. Female cats, which make up approximately 80% of single-cat households, are called queens, after all.

There is little reason to foresee a decrease in the amount of money spent annually on cat food. Cats above all are creatures of habit more than of training, and attempts to go off-market or shop with an eye towards lowering your cat food bill will meet with little success once the cat hears the clinking of spoon on bowl.

Joseph Logue, Contributor

References

1U.S. Pet Ownership & Demographics Sourcebook (2012): https://www.avma.org/KB/Resources/Statistics/Pages/Market-research-statistics-US-Pet-Ownership-Demographics-Sourcebook.aspx

22011/2012 APPA National Pet Owners Survey: http://www.euromonitor.com/dog-food-in-the-us/report

3How Wet Pet Food Is Made: http://www.petfoodinstitute.org/Index.cfm?Page=WetPetFood